Where do I pick up my pies?

You can collect your pies at our booth at 715 Riverside Ave at the Riverside Arts Market on Saturday’s.

Delivery is available locally for members of The Slice Society, pie of the month club.

All pre-orders will be available for pickup between the hours of 10:00 am to 3:00 pm

Can I walk in and get a whole pie of whatever I want, whenever I want?

Yes, our small bake shop does offer whole pies.

How early will I need to place an order on the online to get a pie?

Online pre-orders are taken 24 hours in advance at the latest. The cutoff time is 4 pm for next day pickup. If it is within 24 hours of your preferred pick-up time, please feel free to call and see if we have a pie available that day.

Can I pre-order a pie on the same day I would like to pick it up?

Pies cannot be reserved for same day pick up, but we offer whole pies first come first served Saturday from 10am - 3pm at the Riverside Arts Market in Jacksonville, Florida.

Can I walk in to get a pie for the holidays?

Yes, a limited number of whole pies will be available for pick up during the holiday season on a first come first served basis. Holiday hours may vary from regular business hours so be sure to check our website for more details.

I placed a pre-order for pie and I no longer want the pie, can I cancel?

Pre-ordered pies are made to order. Therefore, 24 hours notice is required for cancellation of a regular pre-order for a refund. Pre-orders for holiday pies must be paid for in advance and are not refundable. Refunds are not offered for pre-ordered pies that are not picked up or picked up after the scheduled pick-up date. If you would like to cancel or change your order, please email: Info@mixedfillingspieshop.com

I forgot to pick up my Pie can I still grab it?

All pre-orders not retrieved by chosen pickup date and time will be donated and no credits will be given.

I ordered a pie for pick up and I found a pie I would like better, can I trade it out?

Pre-ordered pies are made to order. Therefore, a pre-ordered pie can only be traded out when given 24 hours advance notice. Pre-ordered pies cannot be traded out for another type of pie at pick up.

I ordered a pie and I don't want to pick up that day, can I change the pick up date?

Pre-ordered pies are made to order. Therefore, pick up dates for pre-ordered pies can only be changed when given 24 hours advance notice. Changes to pick up dates for pre-ordered holiday pies are reviewed on a case by case basis.

When is online the order cut off time?

All orders must be placed before 4pm on Friday to be available for Saturday pickup.

Do you give refunds?

Unfortunately, at this time we only issue store credits. Depending on circumstances we will accommodate new pickup requests.

Do you ship?

No, sorry but you’ll have to come see us!