visit florida’s #1 pie shop today
and
discover why our pies have captured the hearts and taste buds of pie lovers throughout the state.
One bite, and you'll understand why we're Florida's undisputed pie champions!
whole pies, slices and Pie flights available wed-sat 10a-5p.
take a look at our current menu to preorder now!
eat pie. be happy.
sweet & savory
Mixed Fillings Pie Shop is a charming pie store founded and ran by women in the lively Five Points area of Jacksonville, Florida. Our cozy shop offers a warm and inviting atmosphere to enjoy our delicious pies. We have a variety of pies to choose from, including individual slices, whole pies, and sampler flights, to satisfy everyone's pie cravings. We're open Wednesdays through Saturdays, from 10 am to 5 pm, or until we sell out of pies. Come taste our pies and experience the pure joy they bring to your taste buds and soul.
Homemade Goodness: Every Bite, Every Slice
it’s what’s inside (the pie) that counts.
We never use any dyes or hydrogenated oils.
“our crusts are handmade with real butter,
not margarine, so the flavor and texture are
traditional and flaky.”
Follow our story.
Voted #1 pie shop in Florida
2021 & 2022
-Florida Times Union & Yelp
